Skip to Navigation Skip to Content

In recent years, the United States has seen a significant rise in state-level privacy laws, each offering varying levels of data protection. With the introduction of the American Privacy Rights Act (APRA), however, the goal is to unify these disparate laws under one comprehensive federal framework. Unlike previous federal efforts, which have seen limited success, the APRA has gained substantial momentum, bringing renewed optimism to those advocating for stronger, consistent privacy protections for American citizens.

The APRA, spearheaded by Senators Maria Cantwell and Cathy McMorris Rodgers, aims to create a standardized privacy law that would replace the patchwork of state regulations with uniform protections across the nation. In this article, we will provide a brief overview of APRA’s key provisions, implications for businesses, and more.

Generate your own Privacy Policy in under 5 minutes

Get Started

Overview

On April 7, 2024, the American Privacy Rights Act (APRA) of 2024 was introduced in a bipartisan effort to protect Americans’ privacy rights in a digital era where data collection has become ubiquitous. Under this Act, U.S. citizens would gain new rights, such as the right to access their data, the ability to opt out of targeted advertising, and new protections for sensitive personal information. If passed, the APRA would preempt state-level privacy laws like California’s CPRA, establishing itself as the nation’s primary data privacy standard.

The APRA saw encouraging feedback during committee reviews, ultimately being approved by the Subcommittee on Data, Innovation, and Commerce on May 23, 2024. Proponents of the Act argue that its provisions, while similar in some respects to state laws, would strengthen data privacy protections for all Americans and provide businesses with a more consistent regulatory framework. Key objectives of APRA include:

  • Protecting consumers’ rights to access, control, and delete personal information.
  • Limiting data collection and retention to purposes that are transparent and clearly defined.
  • Holding businesses accountable for data protection through stringent enforcement measures.

Key Provisions & Coverage

The APRA covers a broad range of data types, organizations, and consumer rights. Below are the primary components of the Act:

  1. Definitions & Scope of“Covered Data”
    “Covered Data” under the APRA includes any information that directly identifies, is linked to, or is reasonably linkable to an individual or a device associated with an individual. This includes both common data, like names and contact information, and more sensitive categories of data. Unlike state laws, the APRA’s definition of covered data is broad, akin to the EU’s GDPR. The Act explicitly excludes certain types of information, such as:

    • De-identified Data: Data that cannot be reasonably linked to an individual.
    • Employee Information: Data used solely within the employment context.
    • Publicly Available Information: Data that is readily available to the public, as well as inferences based on such data.
    • Specific Institutional Collections: Data from libraries, museums, and archives with a public mission and lawful acquisitions are also exempted.
  2.  Sensitive Covered Data
    The APRA identifies several categories of sensitive covered data, which require heightened protection:

    • Government Identifiers: Social security numbers and passport numbers.
    • Health and Biometric Data: Includes genetic data, health history, and biometric identifiers.
    • Financial Information: Account details, payment cards, and passwords.
    • Location Data: Precise geolocation data.
    • Private Communications: Non-public communications, including transmission metadata.
    • Online Activity: Detailed browsing histories and activities across various sites.
    • Other Personal Information: Private images, race, religion, sexual behavior, and information related to minors under 17 years of age.
  3.  Affirmative Express Consent
    One of the central tenets of the APRA is affirmative express consent, which requires individuals to actively authorize an organization’s use of their sensitive data. The Act mandates that consent requests must:

    • Clearly distinguish between purposes necessary for fulfilling a requested service and unrelated purposes.
    • Include an accessible withdrawal option, which should be as prominent as the consent option itself.
    • Be easily comprehensible, including in all languages the business operates in.
  4.  Obligations for Covered Entities
    Under the APRA, organizations classified as “Covered Entities” must adhere to a series of stringent requirements designed to protect consumer data and uphold the rights of individuals.

Privacy Policy & Opt-Out Mechanisms

Covered Entities must provide a privacy policy detailing:

    • The types of data collected.
    • The purposes for data processing.
    • Retention policies.

Additionally, entities must provide an opt-out mechanism for targeted advertising. This mechanism should be easy to locate and use, and service providers must be notified of any consumer opt-out requests.

Sensitive Data Transfers & Third-Party Sharing

The APRA requires organizations to obtain explicit consent before sharing sensitive covered data with third parties, especially in contexts unrelated to the original purpose for which the data was collected. For example, an organization must seek explicit consent if it plans to share users’ financial data with an external vendor.

Data Security & Privacy Officers

To enforce compliance, covered entities are required to appoint a data privacy officer or security officer. For larger entities, known as “Large Data Holders,” both roles must be filled. These officers are responsible for overseeing data protection practices and ensuring adherence to the APRA’s requirements.

Data Security Measures

  • Section 9 of the Act mandates that all covered entities adopt reasonable data security measures to protect the availability, integrity, and confidentiality of personal data. This includes implementing technical, administrative, and physical safeguards to reduce risks of unauthorized access or data breaches.

Impact on Businesses

APRA 2024 represents a new era of data compliance for U.S. businesses, requiring considerable operational adjustments to align with federal standards. Key implications for businesses include:

  • Increased Compliance Costs: Businesses will likely face higher costs associated with implementing APRA-compliant systems, such as updating data collection processes, training staff, and possibly hiring privacy officers.
  • Operational Adjustments: Organizations may need to adjust their data collection practices to ensure that only necessary data is collected, which might require changes in marketing and customer relationship management systems.
  • Liability and Penalties: Non-compliance with APRA can result in steep penalties, especially for businesses handling sensitive consumer information, thus raising the stakes for data protection.

By setting a federal privacy standard, APRA seeks to simplify compliance across state lines, reducing the burden for businesses that previously had to navigate multiple state-specific regulations.

Enforcement & Penalties

Who Enforces the APRA?

The APRA’s enforcement is managed by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and state attorneys general (AGs), who can pursue entities found to be in violation of the Act. Violations of the APRA are deemed unfair practices under the FTC Act, allowing the FTC to take action against non-compliant organizations. Additionally, state AGs have the authority to file for injunctive relief, seek damages, and impose penalties on businesses that violate the Act’s provisions.

In a unique move, the APRA also grants individuals a private right of action, allowing them to pursue civil suits for damages or injunctive relief if they believe their privacy rights have been infringed upon. Although not finalized, this private right of action has been met with opposition from certain political leaders, potentially making it a contentious point during final negotiations. Major elements include:

  1. Administrative Penalties: Businesses that violate APRA may be subject to fines that reflect the severity and frequency of violations. Repeated non-compliance can lead to escalated penalties.
  2. Consumer Complaint Mechanism: APRA empowers consumers to lodge complaints with regulatory bodies if they believe their privacy rights have been violated, promoting accountability.
  3. Private Right of Action: In certain cases, consumers may have the right to pursue legal action against businesses that infringe upon their data privacy rights, potentially resulting in restitution.

By enabling both regulatory and consumer-led enforcement, APRA aims to ensure adherence and hold businesses accountable for maintaining consumer privacy standards.

Consumer Rights

APRA empowers consumers with several critical rights that ensure transparency and control over their data. Key consumer rights include:

    1. Right to Information: Consumers are entitled to know what personal information businesses collect, why it is collected, and with whom it is shared.
    2. Right to Data Control: APRA enables consumers to make decisions about how their data is used, including the right to access, correct, delete, and limit the sale of their information.
    3. Right to Protection Against Data Misuse: APRA mandates that businesses take responsibility for protecting consumer data and inform individuals in the event of a breach, allowing them to take necessary precautions.

Large Data Holder Category

One notable feature of the APRA is the creation of a “Large Data Holder” category. Entities meeting any of the following criteria are classified as Large Data Holders:

    • Annual revenue of $250 million or more.
    • The collection, processing, or transfer of data for over 5 million individuals.
    • Possession of sensitive data for over 200,000 individuals.

Large Data Holders face stricter regulatory requirements, such as:

    • Publishing the last ten years of their privacy policies.
    • Conducting biennial privacy impact assessments on their algorithms.
    • Filing annual reports with the FTC on their internal data controls and subject rights processing.

Preemption of State Privacy Laws

Section 20 of the APRA includes a preemption clause that would override all state-level privacy laws, including California’s CPRA, in favor of a unified federal standard. This has sparked opposition from states with their own established privacy regulations. Some state attorneys general, notably from California, have argued that this federal standard would diminish existing protections for their residents, advocating for the APRA to serve as a baseline rather than a ceiling for privacy rights.

Exceptions to this preemption include state laws on student data, contracts, and tort law, which remain unaffected by the APRA.

The Broader U.S. Privacy Landscape

APRA joins other federal efforts aimed at regulating data privacy, such as the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) and sector-specific regulations like the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Unlike these laws, which focus on specific data types or industries, APRA is a comprehensive federal act covering general consumer data. By providing a uniform standard, APRA offers clarity for both businesses and consumers, potentially paving the way for a more cohesive approach to data privacy across the country. States are still permitted to maintain or pass stricter privacy laws, meaning APRA may serve as a baseline, with state-specific privacy rights continuing to evolve alongside.

Comparison to the American Data Privacy Protection Act (ADPPA)

The APRA has drawn comparisons to the American Data Privacy Protection Act (ADPPA), a prior federal privacy proposal. While both aim to establish a national data privacy standard, the APRA offers a broader definition of covered data and adds provisions like the right to opt out of consequential decisions based on data analysis. Additionally, the APRA’s preemption clause and private right of action differ from the ADPPA, which permits civil actions for any violations of the law.

Future Prospects & Legislative Path

The draft Act was most recently revised on May 23, 2024, introducing amendments to the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) of 1998 and adding new requirements, such as creating a centralized system for consumers to request the deletion of their data from data brokers.

Despite its momentum, the APRA faces a challenging path to becoming law. Like previous efforts, such as the ADPPA, the APRA must navigate a complex legislative process and garner sufficient support in both chambers of Congress. The bill has yet to advance beyond committee approval, and the debate over preemption and private rights of action remains divisive.

If passed, the APRA would mark a transformative shift in U.S. data privacy, providing citizens with significant protections while standardizing business compliance obligations across the country. Advocates hope that the bill will continue to gain bipartisan support, ultimately establishing a federal framework that meets the evolving demands of data privacy in the digital age.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How does APRA affect my rights as a consumer in the U.S.?
    APRA enhances your data privacy rights by requiring businesses to disclose data practices, secure consent, and provide options to access, correct, and delete your personal information.
  2. Are businesses required to notify me in the event of a data breach under APRA?
    Yes, APRA mandates that businesses notify consumers promptly in the event of a data breach, giving you an opportunity to take protective measures.
  3. Can I opt out of having my data sold to third parties under APRA?
    Yes, APRA provides consumers the right to opt out of the sale of their personal information, which applies across the U.S.

Wrapping Up

The American Privacy Rights Act (APRA) of 2024 is a pivotal law that introduces significant federal data privacy protections for U.S. consumers, reshaping how businesses handle personal data. By establishing baseline protections and empowering consumers with control over their personal information, APRA fosters a new level of accountability for businesses. For consumers, APRA represents a critical advancement in protecting privacy rights in a digital age, while businesses must adapt to a more regulated data landscape to maintain trust and compliance. As data privacy continues to be a major public concern, APRA is expected to be a foundation for further privacy legislation and standards in the years to come.

For additional support, resources, & more, consider utilizing GetTerms. For more information, you can visit our website here. We offer a simple solution, ensuring you meet legal standards while maintaining user confidence in your data handling practices. Create an account and get started in 5 minutes. For any further questions or assistance, the GetTerms support team is always ready to help.

Generate your own Privacy Policy in under 5 minutes

Get Started